In what is literally a dream come true, The CW announced the next season of Americas Next Top Model will be an all star edition. We have three words, oh.my.god. Naturally, these girls won’t be competing to actually become a model, but for a second chance at winning. We decided to pick our best 15 to make our dream Top Model All Star cast, assuming the winners wont be invited back. We’ve also taken age into consideration, seeing as some of these girls would be entirely too old at this point. Also, we didn’t feel the need to pick someone from every single cast.
Jenah | Cycle 9
She was weird. She was quirky, and the judges held it against her until the very end. If Heather couldn’t win this season, it should have been her.
Analeigh | Cycle 11
Since she’s working on her movie career, and has supporting roles in the upcoming Crazy, Stupid Love and The Green Hornet, we doubt she’d do it. But this girl is so gorgeous and likable it’s sick. We always saw the star potential.
Heather | Cycle 9
Besides Jenah, she was literally the only likable girl in her season. Her struggle with autism was a different spin we hadn’t seen before on this show. And we’d love to see some redemption from that bitch Bianca, who we still don’t like for treating Heather so poorly the entire season.
Jade | Cycle 6
There is nobody, and we mean nobody, more deserving of coming back to TV than Jade. This girl is singlehandedly the most entertaining model of the bunch. Who can forget the “This isn’t Americas Next Top Best Friend,’ comment? Or this. Oh, and this too. She was 26 when she did the show, which means she’s about 96 now, but who cares?
Alison | Cycle 12
Those eyes, those beautiful big eyes. With a nice personality to match.
Tiffany | Cycle 4
To put it simply, because who could forget this? Round 2?
Isis | Cycle 11
She’s got a killer look. She’s hot. And she used to be a he. Nuff said.
Laura | Cycle 13
If she had to lose her season, we’re glad it was in 2nd place to the beautiful Nicole Fox. Possibly the best looking top 2 we’ve seen. If somebody has to represent for the shorter people, it may as well be her.
Melrose | Cycle 7
She was pegged as a bitch from the beginning and she could never manage to break the title. But we really didn’t think so, and her pictures were crazy. We’d love to see more of her.
Angelea |Cycle 14
Because she’s ghetto-fab hilarious.
Bre | Cycle 5
Though her modeling career has taken off, and she’s starred in some commercials, we doubt she’d come back. But she’s one of our favorite contestants ever in one of the best seasons ever.
Anya | Cycle 10
Without a doubt, one of the most interesting looking and beautiful girls this show has had.
Elina | Cycle 11
She’s hot, she’s a ginger, she’s quirky, and she doesn’t take shi* from anyone. Sign her up.
Sheena | Cycle 11
The girl is genuinely witty and a joy to watch. She breaks the model stereotype like nobody else.
Mercedes | Cycle 2
We’re goin’ way back for our last pick. We need someone who’s smart and kind that we can feel good about rooting for. Nobody better than the season 2 runner up.
